Further on, the panel’s second speaker, a lawyer and expert in sustainable digital infrastructures, tried to shed light on how EU law treats data centres and how the latter easily “get away with it”. They stressed on a general lack of transparency in the consumption rates and emissions of data centres. By treating such data as confidential information, and thereby going against the Energy Efficiency Directive, which is a set of rules and obligations for EU’s energy efficiency targets, it appears difficult to find information on, for example, how much water or energy a specific data centre is extracting from local supplies. Additionally, claims for use of sustainable and renewable resources made by such data centres seem to “only exist on paper”, leading the public to wonder what is left obscured from the actions of Big Tech on the environment and their ability to reclaim public spaces.
This is not only against the right to access public information, as everyone should have the right to know how this affects their daily life, but it also brings up deeper questions regarding people’s ability to democratically participate in matters of their own public interest. Showing up to the demonstration and supporting the activists on site is not only a sign that such democratic participation might currently be in danger, but also that we should question our relationship to technology. While Big Tech remains the only one capturing the benefits of AI and such facilities, environmental and socio-economic pressures end up burdening surrounding communities. Therefore, we are asked how to reclaim technology as a site of self-expression and community, far from warlike and genocidal applications.